Researchers at The Norwegian University of Science and Technology (NTNU)’s Department of Psychology have conducted a comprehensive survey of nearly 1,000 toddlers that shows that serious sleep disorders in young children can have long-term consequences.
The study shows that 4-year-olds with sleep disorders have a higher risk of developing symptoms of psychiatric problems as 6-year-olds, compared with children who sleep soundly.
At the same time, 4-year-olds with psychiatric symptoms have a greater risk of developing a sleep disorder as 6-year-olds, compared with children who do not have these kind of symptoms.
“It is common for children to have periods when they sleep poorly, but for some children, the problems are so extensive that they constitute a sleep disorder. Our research shows that it is important to identify children with sleep disorders, so that remedial measures can be taken. Sleeping badly or too little affects a child’s day-to-day functioning, but we are seeing that there are also long term repercussions,” says Silje Steinsbekk, an associate professor and psychologist in NTNU’s Department of Psychology, in a release.
Her previous research on the relationship between sleep disorders and psychological problems in children has shown that 4-year-olds with sleep disorders often also show symptoms of psychiatric problems.
The new study, which was recently published in the Journal of Developmental & Behavioral Pediatrics, shows that the correlation between sleep disorders and psychiatric disorders is also found over time and that the relationship is reciprocal.
Thorough Interviews and Diagnoses
We know that 20% to 40% of young children struggle with sleep in one way or another, but we lack data on how many of them are suffering from a diagnosable sleep disorder.
NTNU researchers conducted diagnostic interviews with the parents of the children participating in the study. The interview was based on the DSM-IV diagnostic manual.
One thousand 4-year-olds participated in the study. Parents of around 800 of these children were interviewed again two years later. The comprehensive study is part of a longitudinal study in Trondheim that examines the incidence, progression, and risk factors for the development of mental health problems in children. The project conducts follow-up visits with the children and their parents every other year.
“Previous studies of sleep problems in children have mainly used a questionnaire format, with questions like, ‘Does your child have trouble sleeping?’ But what parents define as sleep problems will vary. In the diagnostic interview we ask parents questions until we are confident that we have enough information to assess whether a symptom is present or not. The information we’ve collected is more reliable than information obtained from the questionnaire,” says Steinsbekk.
What Comes First?
Can we say that poor sleep causes psychiatric problems—or do psychiatric problems cause poor sleep? The findings from the study suggest that the relationship goes both ways.
One possible explanation for this reciprocity may be that both conditions are biologically determined, by common underlying genetics, for example.
Another explanation may be that insufficient sleep creates general functional impairment, and that the risk of other problems therefore increases—in the same way that psychiatric symptoms often result in poorer everyday functioning, which in turn may negatively affect sleep.
Perhaps sleep disorders and mental health issues share the same risk factors. A child who shows signs of anxiety or a behavioural disorder may easily end up in a vicious cycle, where conflict with adults triggers anxiety and in turn leads to trouble falling asleep.
It may also be that difficult and negative thoughts steal both energy and sleep and make us restless and depressed if we fail to gain control over them.
“Given that so many children suffer from insomnia, and only just over half ‘outgrow it,’ it is critical for us to be able to provide thorough identification and good treatment. Perhaps early treatment of mental health problems can also prevent the development of sleep disorders, since psychiatric symptoms increase the risk of developing insomnia,” says Steinsbekk, stressing that this is something that must be examined in further research.
The study shows that insomnia is the most prevalent sleep disorder. Children who suffer from insomnia struggle with falling asleep and frequent waking. Insomnia was diagnosed in 16.6% of the 4-year-olds surveyed, and 43% of these still had insomnia as 6-year-olds.
Insomnia in 4-year-olds increases the risk for symptoms of anxiety, depression, ADHD, and behavioral problems as 6-year-olds. After the researchers had taken into account the children’s psychiatric symptoms at age 4, the relationship between insomnia and ADHD disappeared.
Similarly, children who show symptoms of anxiety, depression, ADHD, and behavioral disturbances as 4-year-olds have a greater risk of developing insomnia as 6-year-olds. When symptoms of insomnia at age 4 were adjusted for, the relationship between insomnia and anxiety disappeared.
Examples of other types of sleep disorders are hypersomnia and various cases of parasomnia, such as nightmares, night terrors, and sleepwalking. These conditions are uncommon, and the study also shows that, with the exception of sleepwalking, they are shorter-lived.