It is claimed one in five students have taken the “smart” drug modafinil, a pharmaceutical that enhances cognitive functioning in narcolepsy patients, to boost their ability to study and improve their chances of exam success. But new research into the effects of modafinil (also known by the brand name Provigil) has shown that healthy students could actually find their performance impaired by the drug.
The study carried out by Dr Ahmed Dahir Mohamed, in the School of Psychology at The University of Nottingham Malaysia Campus, and published this week in the journal PLOS ONE, showed the drug had negative effects in healthy people.
Mohamed says in a release: “We looked at how the drug acted when you are required to respond accurately and in a timely manner. Our findings were completely opposite to the results we expected.”
In a randomized double blind study, they administered the drug to 32 participants and a placebo to 32. All the participants were given the Hayling Sentence Completion Test in which they were asked to respond both quickly and accurately. Mohamed found the drug slowed down reaction times, impaired their ability to respond in a timely manner, and failed to improve their performance of the task.
Mohamed says: “It has been argued that modafinil might improve your performance by delaying your ability to respond. It has been suggested this ‘delay dependent improvement’ might improve cognitive performance by making people less impulsive. We found no evidence to support those claims.
“Our research showed that when a task required instant reactions, the drug just increased reaction times with no improvement to cognitive performance.”
This backs up the findings of a previous study carried out by Mohamed and published in September 2014 in The Journal of Creative Behaviour. The study, The Effects of Modafinil on Convergent and Divergent Thinking of Creativity: A Randomised Controlled Trial, showed that the so-called “smart” drug impaired the participant’s ability to respond in a creative way particularly when they were asked to respond laterally—outside the box.
Does Modafinil Benefit Anyone?
When Mohamed looked at participants’ ability to problem solve in a creative manner, he found that those who weren’t particularly creative to start with were improved by the drug while those who were creative were impaired by the drug.
He says: “Our study backs up previous research that suggests psychostimulants improve people at the lower end of the spectrum in cognition whereas they impair people who are at the optimum level of cognitive function—healthy people, for example. It looks like modafinil is not helpful for healthy individuals, and it might even impair their ability to respond and might stifle their lateral thinking, while people who have some sort of deficiency in creativity are helped by the drug.”
What Can Make Us Smarter?
Ahmed Mohamed’s research was carried out while he was at Cambridge University. He has since moved to The University of Nottingham Malaysia Campus where he will be looking at the effects of nonpharmacological interventions, such as meditation, exercise, and diet, on the healthy brain. He is also currently using electroencephalography (EEG) to study how mindfulness can affect the healthy adolescent brain.
Mohamed says: “What I have found in my doctoral studies is that if you are already a healthy person and functioning at an optimum level, it is really difficult to improve your cognition. But the brain of the adolescent is still in development and you might be able to improve cognition at this stage of our development through positive interaction, healthy diet, or mindfulness.”